Starfrit MightiCan Can Opener Review: Worth It?

Starfrit MightiCan Manual Can Opener

Photos coming soon.

The short version

Buy it if

Cooks who want the lid off without touching a sharp edge
Left handed users, or households with mixed handedness
People who want a soft knob and handles rather than bare metal

Skip it if

You often drain cans by pressing the lid down
You want the can rim smooth as well as the lid

What owners like

Simple to use once clamped on
Lid stays clamped in the opener, so it goes straight to the bin without touching the edge

Common complaints

The rim left on the can can be sharp, a hazard in the recycling bag
Draining canned tuna or vegetables is awkward because the lid will not press back into the can

Based on A long form owner review on Ken Dyck's blog (2005, an earlier version of the same design) plus product details from Amazon, Newegg and ODP Business listings; independent owner coverage is thin.

Research scores

Does the job 7.0 lid comes off clean and held, but the can rim can stay sharp

Build quality 7.0 warranty listed as 3 years on Amazon, 1 year at other retailers

Ease of use 7.5 soft grip and either hand, though draining cans is awkward

Value 7.5 mid priced for a lid holding safety opener

Scored from the maker's specs and what owners report. Drew's own notes and photos will refine these.

Ownership

Times bought1

Price range$$

Drew's hands-on notes for this product are on the way. Long-term updates will be added to this timeline.

What it does

A manual can opener with a soft grip knob that cuts the lid off cleanly, holds onto it, and leaves no sharp edge on the lid.

Cuts the lid off without leaving a sharp edge on the lid
Grips the lid after cutting so it does not fall into the food
Lid comes off at the same diameter as the opening, so it cannot drop in
Soft grip knob and handles meant to cut down on the hand pressure needed
Works for both right and left handed users

A good fit for anyone who wants to open cans without touching or fishing out a sharp lid, and for lefties, since it works in either hand. The trade-off is that the cut rim of the can itself can still be sharp, and because the lid no longer sits inside the can, pressing it down to drain tuna or beans does not work.

How it compares

OXO Good Grips Smooth Edge Can OpenerReviewed's best safety pick, leaving smooth edges without sharp surfaces$$

EZ-DUZ-IT Deluxe Can OpenerA plain, sturdy opener named best overall by Reviewed, if you want simple and long lasting$$

Kuhn Rikon Auto Safety Lid LifterAnother safety opener, picked by Reviewed as the best for left handed cooks$$

Specs

Type: Manual, lid holding safety opener
Model: 093112-012-BLCK
Handedness: Right or left hand
Size: About 4.4 in wide by 2.2 in high (retailer listing)
Care: Wash with soap and water (retailer listing)
Warranty: 3 years per the Amazon listing; some retailers list 1 year

Worth knowing

The cut rim of the can may be sharp, so handle opened cans with care

Questions

Does the Starfrit MightiCan leave sharp edges?

Not on the lid, which is what the maker promises. One long form owner review found the rim of the opened can could still be sharp.

Is the MightiCan left handed?

Starfrit says it suits both right and left handed users.

Is the Starfrit MightiCan dishwasher safe?

The listings read did not say. One retailer lists cleaning with soap and water, so hand washing is the safe choice.

What warranty does the MightiCan have?

The Amazon listing advertises a 3 year warranty, while some other retailers list a 1 year limited warranty, so check the box when it arrives.

Sources

Researched 2026-10-02. We bought this product; our page is built from the maker's details and what owners report across reviews and forums. We never copy Amazon customer reviews.