O'Keeffe's Lip Repair Cooling Relief Stick, 2 Pack

A cheap, heavy balm for cracked lips, best skipped if peppermint stings.

The short version

Buy it if
  • People whose lips get very dry or cracked, especially in winter
  • Anyone who likes a cooling, minty feel from a lip balm
Skip it if
  • Peppermint or menthol products tend to sting or irritate your lips
  • You want a balm with SPF, which this formula does not list

What owners like

    Common complaints

      Based on The O'Keeffe's product page, two ingredient analysis sites (INCIDecoder and What's in My Jar) and the Amazon listing title. No owner reviews or editorial tests could be read for this product, so no owner themes are reported..

      Research scores

      Does the job 7.1 occlusive formula made for cracked lips, though no owner tests were found
      Quality 6.8 solid moisturizers, but peppermint oil is a flagged irritant
      Ease of use 8.0 a standard stick applied as often as needed
      Value 8.0 low price band for a two pack

      Scored from the maker's specs and what owners report. Drew's own notes and photos will refine these.

      Ownership

      Owned sinceNov 2025
      Owned for11 months
      Times bought1
      Price range$
      1. Nov 2025

        First bought.

      Drew's hands-on notes for this product are on the way. Long-term updates will be added to this timeline.

      What it does

      A two pack of beeswax and petrolatum lip balm sticks with peppermint oil for a cooling feel, made for very dry, cracked lips.

      • Stick format that goes on like a standard lip balm
      • Peppermint oil gives a cooling feel on contact
      • The maker says it forms a flexible barrier that lasts through eating and drinking
      • Contains seven moisturizing ingredients, according to the maker
      • The maker offers a money back guarantee

      A low cost, heavy duty balm for people whose lips crack in cold or dry weather and who like a minty cooling feel. The trade-off is the peppermint oil, which ingredient guides flag as a possible irritant, so people with sensitive lips may do better with an unscented balm.

      How it compares

      O'Keeffe's Lip Repair UnscentedBetter if peppermint stings or you want a balm with no cooling feel$
      Aquaphor Lip Repair StickBetter if you want a widely sold petrolatum based stick from a different brand$

      Specs

      Count
      2 sticks
      Size
      0.15 oz per stick
      Main moisturizers
      Beeswax, dimethicone, petrolatum, shea butter, sweet almond oil
      Cooling agent
      Peppermint oil
      Scent
      Menthol, from peppermint oil
      Other formats
      Single stick and 0.35 oz tube

      Worth knowing

      • Contains peppermint oil, which ingredient guides note can irritate sensitive skin.
      • Contains sweet almond oil, a nut derived ingredient.

      Questions

      What makes O'Keeffe's Cooling Relief cool?

      Peppermint oil in the formula, which has a menthol scent and gives the cooling feel.

      How do you use O'Keeffe's Lip Repair?

      The maker says to apply it liberally as needed, regularly through the day, especially after eating or drinking, and before bed.

      What is the difference between O'Keeffe's Cooling Relief and Unscented?

      Cooling Relief adds peppermint oil for a cooling feel. The Unscented version leaves it out.

      What size is the O'Keeffe's lip repair stick?

      Each stick is 0.15 oz. The 2 pack has two sticks.

      Sources

      Researched 2026-10-02. We bought this product; our page is built from the maker's details and what owners report across reviews and forums. We never copy Amazon customer reviews.

      7.4O'Keeffe's Lip Repair Cooling Relief Stick, 2 Pack Check price